Juniper Publishers: Hirsutism-A Comprehensive Update of Embryology, Aetiopathogenesis and Therapeutic Approach
JUNIPER PUBLISHERS- JOURNAL OF GYNECOLOGY AND WOMEN’S
HEALTH
Journal of Gynecology and Women’s Health-Juniper
Publishers
Authored by Kulvinder Kochar Kaur*
Abstract
Hirsutism, defined as terminal hair on the body of a
female, affects 5-10% of women. Of these the commonest cause is
anovulation secondary to PCOS, which is a fairly common disorder
affecting 6-10%of women of reproductive age group. Although ovary is the
main source of androgen excess, evidence with synthesis of androgens
from adrenals is exaggerated with 25-50% of PCOS patients showing an
adrenal androgen excess. Besides PCOS other hormonal causes like thyroid
hormone deficiency, growth hormone deficiency, or hyperprolactinemia,
hyperinsulinemia which may act on their own or synergistic increase with
adrenal androgens. A serum T over 2ng/ml, warrants exploring for an
androgen secreting tumor. Although in some cases of PCOS massive
virilization deepening of voice, receding hairline with a normal
karyotype has been reported in the absence of a tumor, it just needs
simple treatment efforts of controlling hyperandrogenemia.
In this review we have comprehensively reviewed the
embryology of hair growth, the aeitiopathogenesis of hirsutism along
with therapeutic approach. Contrary to commonly used preparations
containing cyproterone, oral contraceptives like preparations having low
dose ethinyl estradiol and drosperinone with low dose flutamide 75mg
remains the choice of treatment in unmarried girls not desiring
pregnancy and in married women also it is these OC’s for 6 months may be
the first choice of drug and although ovulation induction and insulin
sensitizers may help in achieving pregnancy they do not treat the
hirsutism. Role of spironolactone cream, finasteride cream are discussed
as well. Although eflornithine hydrochloride (Vasqua) is available as a
facial cream, the author has not found its efficacy and hence it is not
discussed. Similarly although other agents like cemetidine may have
some effects, they are not the primary drugs of choice, hence are not
discussed.
Abbreviations:PCOS:
Polycystic Ovary Syndrome; NCAH: Non Classical Adrenal Hyperplasia; IH:
Idiopathic Hirsutism; FU: Follicular Unit; SHBG: Sex Hormone Binding
Globulin; CT: Computed Tomography; MRI: Magnetic Resonance Imaging; USG:
UltrasonographyIntroduction
Hirsutism is defined as the terminal hair on the body
of a female patient which is distributed in a male like pattern. It
affects roughly 5-10%of women [1-3]. Presence of hirsutism evokes lot of stress and affects psychosocial development [4-6].
In most women hirsutism indicates, the presence of one of the
conditions like the polycystic ovary syndrome (PCOS), androgen producing
tumors, non classical adrenal hyperplasia (NCAH)orsyndromes of severe
insulin resistance, than being an isolated disorder. Occasionally it may
not be because of any of these causes when it is termed as idiopathic
hirsutism (IH) or peripheral hirsutism. Although often it is referred to
as familial hirsutism, but this should not be used for IH as it has
been shown that other causes of hyperandrogenism like PCOS and NCAH,
show a strong familial distribution [7,8].
Embryology of hair growth
Hair follicle development starts at around 9-12 weeks
[9,10], and gets derived from the epidermis. It is mainly a solid
column of cells which proliferate starting from the basal layers of the
epidermis and protrude downwards into the dermis. Once this elongates it
meets a bundle of mesodermal cells (dermal papilla), which it envelops
at the bulbous tip known as bulb. This solid epithelial column then
hollows out to form a hair canal, and the pilosebaceous unit (a hair
follicle, sebaceous glands and anterior pili muscles) get laid down.
Colour of hair is decided by pigments which get produced by melanocytes
in the bulb.
The growth of hair starts with the proliferation of
epithelial cells at the base of the canal in contact with the dermal
papilla. The fetus is covered with lanugo hair, which is lightly
pigmented, has a thin diameter, short in length, and are attached very
fragilely. Total endowment of hair follicles is made as early as 22weeks
of gestation age and no new follicles get produced denovo. The total
number of hair are approximately 50million hair follicles, which cover
the body, of these 100,000-150,000are present on the scalp, while rest
are present on facial and body areas. Only areas which are devoid of
hair are feet, palms of hand and lips [11,12].
The concentration of hair follicles which get laid
down / unit area of facial, skin does not differ materially between
sexes but does differ between races and ethnic groupsof white>asia;
mediteranean>Nordic. Also hair growth differences between different
races reflects hair follicle differences in 5α- reductaseRA(5-α-RA)[13].
This pattern is genetically determined.
Hair structure and function
Hair grows cyclically, rather than in a continuous
fashion, having alternating phases of activity and inactivity. There are
3 cycles i) Anagen-the growing phase ii) Catagen-rapid involution phase
iii) Telogen-quiescent phase.
In telogen/resting phase there are short hairs which
are loosely attached to the base of the bulb of the epithelial canal. At
the initiation of growth in anagen, matrix cells present at the base
begin to proliferate followed by descending into the dermis. This
epithelial column enlarges 4-6 times from the resting phase. On
completion of downward growth, rapid growth of the matrix cells
continuously, pushes upwards to the skin surface. The contact with
previous hair is broken, followed by shedding of the hair. The
superficial matrix cells form a keratinized column. On finishing,
catagen or rapid involution of the column occurs by shrinkage, along
with shriveling of the bulb, terminating in the resting phase or
telogen.
The length of hair is determined by the time the hair
grows in anagen. Scalp hair remains in anagen for 2-5years with a
relative short resting phase. In the rest of body like forearm, a short
anagen and a long telogen leads to short hair having stable nongrowing
length. Presence of continuous hair growth/ shedding periodically
depends on the degree to which individual hair follicles are
asynchronous from their neighbours. Scalp hair being asynchronous,
always seem to be growing. The resting phase of some hairs-approximately
10-15% is not apparent. In case marked synchrony is achieved, leading
to simultaneous telogen at the same time, simultaneous shedding
culminates in a process known as telogen effluvium. Rarely women
complain of rapid hair loss from scalp, this being a temporary
phenomenon-lasting usually 6-8 months is followed by resumption of hair
growth, on reestablishment of hair synchrony. Causes of telogen
effluvium include, pregnancy, fever and drugs. Still measuring thyroid
stimulating hormone is important to rule out any thyroid disease.
There are three types of hair structurally. Soft hair
covering skin of fetus is lanugo which gets shed in 1-4 months
postpartum. Vellus hairs are nonpigmented usually, measuring <2mm in
length and cover the areas of body which are apparently hairless.
Histologically vellus hairs have a diameter, which does not exceed
10.03mm, smaller in diameter as compared to the investing root sheath
[14]. Lastly terminal hair is longer, coarse in texture and are
pigmented. These make up the eyebrows, hairlashes, axillary and pubic
hair in both sexes, and most of the body and facial hair in men [15].
These hairs are usually medullated. Innermost area of terminal hair
follicles is called medulla, and is considered to be a collapsed
protein’ although its exact composition is controversial. This medulla
is missing in lanugo and vellus hairs. Hair follicles form groups in
skin, which are called follicular unit (FU), each FU consists of 3-4
follicles along with sebaceous glands and connective tissue sheath
[16,17]. No gender difference exists regarding FU, and basic difference
in men and women don’t relate to number of FU’s but to the type and
quality of hair.
Hypertrichosis implies increased hair of the
fetal-lanugo type in a generalized fashion, usually secondary to drugs
or malignancy. Vellus hairs are the ones present in prepubertal girls,
which are unpigmented. While coarse, pigmented hair, which grow on
various parts of the body during the adult years are referred to as
terminal hairs. Hirsutism means a transformation from vellus to terminal
hair.
Factors influencing hair growth
Dermal papilla holds the key regarding hair growth
will continue despite any injury, freezing, xrays. Even with severe
injury once dermal papilla survives, hair follicle will regenerate,
followed by regrowth of the hair. Damaging the dermal papilla like by
laser or electrolysis properly only ensures complete hair removal.
Basically sex steroids, multiple local factors as
well as systemic factors act directly or indirectly on the dermal
papilla for regulating the hair growth. Also the same factor may act on
the rest of the hair follicle, which includes the outer and inner root
sheaths and the follicular stem cells of the bulge area [18] and these
may be as important as the dermal papilla for regulating the growth of
hair. Of the local and systemic factors different growth factors, and
cytokines, have been shown to affect hair growth [18-22]. Suggestions
that these factors act by increasing the synthesis of stromolysin a
matrix matalloproteinse which acts on the dermal papilla toincrease the
growth [23]. Hormones like thyroid hormone (TH) [24,25] and GH [26],
also can affect hair growth. Generally it is the deficiency of TH/GH, be
it disease associated or drug induced, is usually associated with
changes in the anagen-telogen ratio in scalp and body hair [26,27].
In case of TH treatment in hypothyroid patients,
usually leads to regrowth of scalp hair within approximately 8weeks
[24]. TH receptors have been proved to be present on the outer sheath
cells of the hair follicles, with a positive effect of c-T3 on the
cellular proliferation in cultured hair follicles [28]. Even in GH
deficient men who are treated with substitution of GH, shows an increase
in body hair which occurs without any observable free androgen index
[26].
This suggests that GH can directly stimulate body
hair which is independent of circulating androgens getting raised.
Binding of GH has been shown in the layers of the lower one thirds of
the follicle, the outer sheath of the upper two third of the follicle
and the dermal papilla [27]. Notwithstanding a direct growth effect of
GH on ‘invitro’ follicles growth or morphology has not been observed
[29]. There is a possibility that the effect of GH is modulated through
insulin like growth f actor 1(IGF1). Fibroblasts in human scrotal skin
showed IGF1 but no increase in IGFII or insulin, causing an increase in
5-αRA, an enzyme necessary for the potentiation of the androgen effect
[29]. Also in culture conditions, IGF1, but not IGFII or insulin caused
stimulation of hair follicle growth [30].
Of the sex steroids androgens are the most essential
in deciding the distribution of hairs as well as types of hairs over the
human body. Androgens can exert action like hair follicles which are
producing vellus types of hair to convert them to produce terminal hair.
Under in vivo conditions, exogenous androgens affect the
differentiation of hair follicles in androgen sensitive areas of the
body like genitalia and facial beard areas in normal males or eunuchs
and female to male transsexuals [31].
Besides stimulating terminal hair production,
androgens also prolong the anagen phase of the body hairs, while
simultaneously reducing the anagen phase of scalp hairs [32,33]. They
also increase sebum secretion. Thus they increase body hair along with
their oiliness.
Control of GnRH secretion in PCOS
Mahesh VB reviewed the control of steroidogenesis
investigation work of his from 1956 to 2010 regarding hirsutism,
virilization and PCOS, They found that in ovariectomized rats P was a
major enhancer of E induced gonadotropin release ovulatoryGn Surge.
Manifestation of P effects were manifested by the depletion of their
occupied E receptors of the anterior pituitary, hypothalamic GnRH
release and inhibition of enzymes which degrade GnRH.P promotes the
synthesis of selective LH release and acted using GABA A receptor
system. ASelective release of FSH was induced by the 5 α reduced
metabolite of P and P’s ability to selectively induce FSH release
depended on getting converted to 5α reduced metabolite. Since GnRH
neurons do not have steroid receptors, this effect was brought about by
the excitatory amino acid glutamate, which further requires stimulation
from nitic oxide. The effect of P was mediated on the 361 base pair
region of the FSH promoter gene [34]. Although their has been
controversy regarding Gn RH neurons having estrogen β receptors, which
may have a role, besides kisspeptin neurons, which also possess E
receptors, multiple pathways may be utilized, and this effect of these
hormones using the steroid receptors present on glutamatergic neurons
may be additional mechanism [reviewed in ref 35].
Androgen production
Normally in females testosterone (T) production rate
is around 0.2- 0.3mg/day. Peripheral conversion of androstendione (An)
contributes to approximately 50% of T whereas 25% of circulating T comes
from adrenal gland and ovary respectively, except at midcycle where
ovarian contribution is just 10-15%. Dehydroepiandrosterone sulphate
(DHAS) comes exclusively from adrenal gland, while 90% of
dehydroepiandrosterone (DHA) comes from adrenal.
Of the circulating T 80% is bound to a β globulin
also known as sex hormone binding globulin (SHBG). Approx imately in
women 19% is loosely bound to albumin, and 1% remains unbound. In
contrast DHA, DHASand An do not bind to protein significantly, with the
routine RIA reflecting the available biological activity of these
hormones. While routine assays in case of T measure bound and unbound
concentratons. Androgens decrease SHBG production in liver. Thus in men
binding capacity is lower than in women with 2-3% of T circulating in
free active form. Insulin decrease SHBG, while estrogen and thyroid
hormone increase it. Hence in hyperthyroidism, pregnancy and estrogen
containing medicines the binding capacity is in creased. Excess
androgens depress SHBG in hirsute women, besides by hyperinsulinemia if
present. The Total T maybe within normal limits in a hirsute woman.
Since the very presence of hirsutism and/or masculinization, indicates
increased andogen there is no indication for testing free T. One can
presume lower binding capacity and raised freeT.
Only 25% of circulating T comes from peripheral
conversion in hirsute women and maximum is due to direct glandular
secretion. Data indicated with increased androgen production that ovary
is the major source of raised T and An in hirsute woman [36]. Commonest
cause of hirsutism in women is persistent anovulation, associated with
increased androgen production. Adrenal causes are very uncommon.
DHT metabolism
Though T is the main circulating androgen, dihydroT
(DHT), is the major nuclear androgen in many sensitive tissues, which
includes hair follicles and the Pilosebaceous unit in the skin. DHT gets
metabolized to 3-α-androstanediol in the peripheral tissues and its
glucuronide form 3-αAG is utilized in the form of a markerof target
tissue cellular activity [37-38]. 3α-AGcorrelates with the level of 5-α
reductase activity [(5-α RA) (T and An)] in the skin. This makes 3
important laboratory measurements i) T-which is a measure of ovarian and
adrenal activity ii) DHAS-being a measure of adrenal activity iii) 3-α
AG, a measure of peripheral target tissue activity.Hirsutism, basically
is not a disorder of hair, but rather it shows the raisedactivity of
5-αRA, which reflects greater DHT production. Activity of this enzyme
reflects greater availability of precursori. e. circulating T, which is
the primary factor or by some unknown local tissue mechanisms which are
still unclear. Once other laboratory measurements are normal raised 3-α
AG reflects an increased activity of 5-α RA in the peripheral component
[39]. But 3-AGcan also reflect conjugation activity in liver and the
effect of various major precursors derived from adrenal and not from
peripheral sources [40] Thus 3-α AG is not the sole measure of skin
androgen metabolism. Usually there is not much benefit of testing 3-α AG
as i) it is not an absolute measurement with 20% overlap in hirsute
women and ii) the ultimate final treatment is not going to affect either
the diagnosis or the therapy.
Prostate specific antigen (PSA)
PSA is basically a serine protease produced by the
prostate gland, thus used as a tumor marker for diagnosis along with
management of prostate cancer. PSA has also been detected in female
tissues, measurable by very sensitive assays. Since androgens increase
PSA gene, one can expect increased circulating PSA in women with
hyperandrogenism. Circulating levels of 3-α AG correlate with the
increased PSA in hirsute women [41]. There is no response to
ovarian/adrenal stimulation, which indicates a widespread origin [,43].
Right now no clinical applications of measuring PSA exist in women.
Scoring degree of hirsutism
On the basis of direct watching of hair type as well
as their growth in cases who are suspected to have hisutism, the treaing
physician has to decide whether hair are of terminal coarse or vellus
type, besides if a male type of pattern is present as diagnosis is a
subjective process. If the vellus hairs are the only ones increased, it
does not point to hyperandrogenemia, and can be caused by familial or
ethnic causes, abnormalities of corticosteroid, GH, or Thyroid hormone
production, or can be druginduced. Though one can easily distinguish
vellus hair from terminal hairs because of different texture,
thicknessas well as pigmentation many patients of hyperandrogenism will
have increased hair of bothtypes. The term hypertrichosis mainly refers
to excessive growth strictly. Initially Ferriman and Gallwey introduced
the methods of determining the degree of hirsutism visually, using
scoring based on density of terminal hairs in 11 body sites which
included upperlip, chin, chest, upper back, lower back, upper abdomen
lower abdomen, arm, forearm, thigh and lowerleg in 161women between ages
of 18-39 years attending their OPD [1].
Scoring was from 0 (absence of terminal hair to 4
extensive terminal hair growth) and they found scoring over forearm and
lowerleg was found to be less sensitive, or less sensitive to androgens,
thus a modified Ferriman and Gallwey method was introduced which
excluded forearm and lowerleg [44,45]. Hair, growth over sideburns,
lower jaw, upper neck and buttocks has been introduced in recent studies
[46]. Originally Ferriman and Gallwey found the inclusion of only
9’hormonal’ skin areas after excluding lower legand forearm were taken
into consideration. Of the 161 women having a score above5,4.3%-of these
9%had a score of >7and 1.2%had a score>10 [1].
Thus considering a score>8 is supposed to
represent hirsutism. Problem was that these initial studies were mainly
carried out in white people. Though the variations in the distribution,
number, or androgen sensitivity of hair follicles is normal, individuals
in various racial and ethnic groups needs to be defined in a better
way. The information regarding prevalence of hirsutism in these various
groups is very little. Hence [47] retrospectively performed a study on
369 consecutive reproductively aged black (n=195) and white (n=174)
women who had been examined at the time of their employment by their
preemployment physician [48]. They used a modification of
Ferriman-Galleyway method [46], in which<9 body areas were assessed.
Their observation was 7.6%, 4.6%and 1.9% demonstrated a modified
Ferriman Galleyway score>=6, 8 or 10 respectively.
The overall s core which is used to cutoff would fall
with the decrease in number of areas assessed (or the maximum score
assigned to each area) is reduced.e.g. 300 unselected female medical
patients using modified-Ferriman-Galleyway score where only 5 areas of
body were scored like chin, upper lip, chest abdomen and thighs was
studied by Lorenzo et al [45]. They did not find a score of>5in any
of these women. Although the exact cut off score used in white women and
7.1%, 6.1% and 2.1% of black women having a score >6, 8 and
10respectively [47]. But some investigators found as compared to white
women Asian women relatively rarely had hirsutism [49-51]. In view of
that just absence of hirsutism cannot be considered as a feauture of
absence of hyperandrogenism.
Evaluation of hirsutism
A Number of factors determine that cosmetically disturbing hirsutism will ensue
i) number of hair follicles present-since Asian women
having androgen producing tumors are occasionally hirsute in lieu of
the low concentration of hair follicles/unit skin area ii) The degree of
resting vellus hairs conversion to terminal adult hair by androgens
iii) Ratio of growth to resting phases in affected hair iv) Asynchrony
of growth cycles in aggregates of hair follicles v) The thickness and
degree of pigmentation of individual hairs.
The initial factor is an increase in androgen levels
(usually), which produces an initial growth stimulus and then acts for
sustaining continued growth. Ultimately nearly every woman with
hirsutism will have increased production of T and An [51].
Anovulatory women who are not hirsute usually show
laboratory evidence of increased androgen production [52,53]. But the
commonest complaint made by women who have increased androgen production
is hirsutism. Other complaints in order of frequency are acne,
increased oiliness of skin, increased libido, clitoromegaly and lastly
masculinization. E xtreme androgen effects lead to masculinizaion,
virilization, which is not always associated with a tumor which leads to
a male hair pattern, clitoromegaly, deepening of voice, increased
muscle mass and a general male like habitus.
Although Ferriman-Gallwey scoring system and its
modifications have been used to quantify the amount of hirsutism, they
are of little clinical use. Such systems are basically meant for studies
of hirsutism, but even for that purpose they have their limitations due
to subjective variability [54-56].
The biggest problem for a patient is alopecia and
same is troublesome for clinician as well. Many a times it is temporary
with synchronous growth and loss of hair, which can be secondary to some
acute stressful event. Near the end of pregnancy or postpartum telogen
effluvium often occurs. As time progresses hair growth becomes
asynchronous and hair thickens again within 6months to 1year.
In a study carried out on consecutive patients with
diffuse alopecia, majority had no hirsutism or menstrual dysfunction,
but they had evidence of polycystic ovaries and almost 40% showed
hyperandrogenemia [57]. Patients presenting with alopecia need a
thorough workup as regard to hyperandrogenemia as most of them can be
treated. Besides that one should rule out thyroid hormone dysfunction or
any chronic illness. Still as alopecia reflects scalp 5-α RA, normal
circulating hormone levels should not stop one from treating [57,58]. As
a result of ageing as well hair loss occurs, in both sexes starting at
age 50 [59].
Acne also reflects raised androgen activity. About
60%of women having normal circulating levels of androgens with acne
display evidence of raised 5-αRA, in the pilosebaceous unit [60]. These
women benefit from antiandrogen treatment.
Acanthosis nigrans (AN) in an overweight patient,
along with hirsutism-is a marker of insulin resistance and
hyperinsulinemia. This is a grey brown velvety skin discoloration of the
skin present usually in neck, groin and axillae; but vulva is a very
common site in hirsute women. AN indicates the requirement for testing
the glucose metabolism. Thus hyperinsulinemia requires serious
consideration, in hyperandrogenic women.
Commonest clinical problem is the hirsute woman with
irregular cycles, with the onset of hirsutism during teenage years/in
ealy 20’s, which worsens gradually once of longstanding duration [50].
Almost 70%of anovulatory women develop hirsutism. The characteristic
picture can usually be diagnosed by history and detailed examination.
With a good history some rare conditions can be
diagnosed-e.g. environmental factors producing chronic irritation or
reactive hyperaemia of the skin, use of drugs, changes associated with
Cushing’s Syndrome, acromegaly, or even the presence of pregnancy
(indicating a luteoma). Hirsutism can be caused by methyl testosterone,
phenytoin, diazoxide, danazol, cyclosporins, and minoxidil. Drugs which
are not typically androgens cause fine hairs, which are distributed over
trunk and face diffusely, also referred to as hypertrichosis. The
19-nortestosterone in the current low dosage oral contraceptives rarely
(if ever) cause acne or hirsutism. DHEAS or An, which are available as
food supplements, raise T levels in women and thus can be a cause for
hirsutism, even at low doses used.
If a patient over 25 develops very rapid development
of hirsutism which progresses to maculinization over several months to a
year usually points to the presence of an androgen secreting tumor.
Late onset NCAH which is caused by enzymatic
deficiency, present in adult life is rare, and gets dia gnosed only in
1-5% of hyperandrogenic women [61,62]. The classical adrenal hyperplasia
(CAH) which can lead to hirsutism usually gets diagnosed before
puberty. If hirsutism occurs in childhood, usual cause is CAH or
androgen producing tumors. Genetic causes like Y containing mosaics, or
incomplete androgen sensitivity, produce signs of androgen stimulation
at puberty.
If during pregnancy virilization is occurring one
should suspect a luteoma, which basically is not a true tumor, but
occurs only because of excessive reaction of the ovarian stromato even
normal level of HCG [63]. In trophoblastic diseases one sees
theca-lutein cyst salso called hyperreactio-luteinalis are always
bilateral, while solid luteoma is usually unilateral, being present in
45% and always associated with pregnancy [64,65]. In 30%of pregnancies
associated with theca-lutein cysts virilization occurs. Hyperreactio
luteinalis is also seen with the high titres of HCG seen with multiple
gestations. As luteoma regresses following delivery only worrisome thing
is the fetus getting masculinized. Usually following pregnancies are
normal but for occasional recurrence of maternal virilization [66]. Rare
case reports of maternal virilization which has been occasssionally
recurrent are reported with PCOS pregnancies, which should be regarded
as examples of hyperreactio luteinalis [67,68].
The presence of androgen secreting tumors is very
rarely encountered along with pregnancy, possibly as raised androgens
suppress anovulation [25,26]. Ultrasonography (USG) of pelvis can help
in diagnosis in women suffering from virilization during pregnancy. In a
solid unilateral ovarian tumor, malignancy is commonly seen.
Thus mostly it is anovulation which is usually cause
of hirsutism, but a minimal tests towards ruling out ovarian tumors as
well as adrenal tumors is needed.
Workup for Hirsutism
Medical History in detail and thorough physical
examination are very important. Presentation of patient usually
corresponds with ano vulation and polycystic ovaries; in the time
course. A search for galactorrhea thoroughly is important in an
anovulatory patient, besides testing the serum prolactin and thyroid
function tests. Following that laboratory investigations are directed
towards making a diagnosis of insulin resistance, adrenal hyperplasia or
an androgen secreting tumor.
One starts with testing serum testosterone (T) and
17α-hydroxyprogesterone (17-OHP). Now the testing of DHEAS is no longer
considered essential. It is important to screen for TSH even in patients
with alopecia. Those patients, who have severe hyerandrogenemia, may
present with amenorrhea, secondary to endometrial suppression (along
with a decidual response) and thus may not get a withdrawl bleed with a
progesterone (P).
One of the commonest referral is regarding Cushing’s
syndrome, which although can cause hirsutism and masculinization it
usually does not turn out to be the diagnosis in most of the cases. Only
if suspicion high a screen for Cushing’s syndrome is indicated.
Evaluation of cushing’s syndrome (CS)
Persistent oversecretion of cortisol is known as CS. Their are five ways by which it can be produced
- Pituirtary adrenocorticptropic hormone (ACTH) overproduction is the true CS
- Ectopic ACTH overproduction by tumours
- Autonomous cortisol secretion by the adrenal
- Very rarely autonomous cortisol secretion by the ovarian tumor
- Very rarely secretion of CRH by a tumor.
One must first make a diagnosis of CS before looking
for etiology. Most important is the basal state measurement for
detecting CS and 24hrs urinary free cortisolexcretion (10-90µg) and late
evening plasma cortisol level <15µg/dL. ls Start with a single dose
overnight dexamethasone test where dexamethasone 1mg is given orally at
11pmand a plasma cortisol is drawn at 8.00am in the nexr morning. A
value <than 5µg/dL rules out CS. CS is unlikely, with intermittent
values of 5-10µg/dL, whereas having a value >10µ/dL Is diagnostic of
adrenal hyperfunction. The patients who show normal suppression in the
single dose overnight dexamethasone of CS is negligible<1% [69].
False positive rate is 13%in obese patients. If single dose overnight
test is abnormal, establish the diagnosis by measuring 24hr urinary free
cortisol.
Abnormal single dose overnight suppression can make
the diagnosis by getting 24 hr urinary free cortisol. With the 2 day low
dose suppression test final diagnosis gets confirmed. Giving
dexamethasone 0.5mg every 6 hrs x2days oncebaseline24hr urinary
17hydroxy steroid as well as free cortisol gets measured. Patients with
CS will not get the urinary steroids <25g/day and free
cortisol<10µg on 2ndday of dexamethasone suppression.
Once one combines the lower dose test with the 24hr
urinary free cortisol, diagnosis of CS gets confirmed. Having a 24hr
urinary free cortisolof 250µg/day is almost diagnostic, while a level of
200µg gives 90%accuracy.
There is pseudo cortisolism in patients having mild
hypercortisolism, secondary to alcoholism, anorexia nervosa, bulimia,
severe obesity, extremes of stress, depression. Mostly not necessary if
one combines the low dose dexamethasone suppression with CRH
suppression, one can accurately distinguish the true CS from the pseudo
hypercortisolism due to these various conditions [70]. 2days following
low dose dexamethasone suppression, a single plasma cortisol level is
obtained after 15’ of giving 1µg/Kg iv. A cortisol level>1.4µg/dl
needs further evaluation.
One can find out the etiology of CS after combining a
high dose dexamethasone suppression (2mg every 6hrs)x2days, and urinary
17hydroxy steroids and cortisol levels on the 2nd day comparing it with
the basal levels. Once this basal ACTH concentration can be measured in
the blood >20pg/ml, an ectopic ACTH producing tumor is not likely,
if the urinary steroids decrease by at least 40%. Cushing’s disease is
present if blood ACTH level s of plasma are >50pg/ml, which suggests
an ectopic ACTH release, while a low level <5pg/ml suggests an
autonomous cortisol secretion.
To diagnose adrenal tumors imaging is very reliable
and accurate. Besides that it predicts which patient maybe having
ectopic ACTH producing tumor, by finding bilateral enlarged adrenal
glands in such patients. Computed tomography(CT) scanning of adrenal
gland gives better resolution, being preferred over magnetic resonance
imaging(MRI) and ultrasonography(USG).
Evaluating CS can give inconclusive results and a
failure to recognize occult, ectopic ACTH secreting tumor can lead to
unnecessary pituitary or adrenal surgery. Bilateral venous sampling
obtained from the inferior petrosal sinuses (samples draining the blood
draining from the pituitary gland)for the measurement of ACTH, before as
well as following CRH stimulation is a good method of achieving
accurate diagnosis of a pituitaty origin of the ACTH [69]. Roughly 15%of
patients with ACTH dependent CS willhave anoccult, ectopic source for
ACTH. Mostly these ACTH secreting lesions are present in thorax (usually
small cell lung carcinoma) and some are in abdomen. One recommends
petrosal sinus sampling in all patients with ACTH dependent CS, who do
not have an obvious adenal tumoron imaging. Very rare cause of CS is the
autonomous production of cortisol by an ovarian tumor [71]. It is
recommended to do chest and abdomen imaging in for all atypical
presenting cases
DHAS
DHAS is almost exclusively derived from the adrenal
gland and circulates in higher concentrations as compared to any other
steroids. Thus it gives a direct measure of steroid androgen activity
which correlated with the urinary 17-keto steroids clinically. It has an
upper limit of 350µg/dL in most laboratories, but because of laboratory
to laboratory variations one should consider the normal reference range
of the laboratory.
Just a single DHAS sample is enough for hirsuism
evaluation, which needs no correlation for body weight, creatinine
excretion or episodic variation. Variations go to a minimum as this has a
high circulating concentration and has a long half life. A slow
turnover ensures stable pool in hirutism. Hence DHAS serves as a
prehormone in hair follicles, providing substrate for the hair follicle
synthesis of androgens [72]. Both 17KS and DHAS levels are raised in
association with hyperprolactinemia [73,74]. Once prolactin is
suppressed with the use of dopamine agonists these levels return to
normal. Also besides raised DHAS levels T is found in hyperprolactinemia
[75,76]. Hence it is very important to look for galactorrhea in all
anovulatory patients. Androgen levels are secondary to persistent
anovulatory changes, caused by hyperprolactinemia, although direct
effects of prolactin on the adrenal, ovary or SHBG are possible.
With normal DHAS levels, adrenal tumors are rare.
Further evaluations of such cases are dependent on having markedly
raised T [77]. These tumors, which are rare, respond to LH, which
suggests they maybe derived from embryonic rest cells.
One frequently finds moderately increased DHAS levels
in anovulatory women with PCOS. If 17 –hydroxy progesterone is normal,
it is not worthwhile to search for an adrenal enzyme defect. Mostly
clinical experience tells that moderate increases in DHAS are associated
with anovulation and suppression of ovarian function restores the DHAS
levels to normal.
DHAS levels>700µg/dl has been accepted as abnormal
adrenal function. But these levels are rarely found. Even if these
DHAS>=700µg/dl is confronted; it will be associated with an increased
T, either by direct secretion or peripheral conversion from DHAS. Hence
in absence of CS, measurement of DHT is sufficient to screen for
adrenal abnormalities. Getting an imaging study of adrenal glands once T
is raised, it is more cost effective than measuring DHAS levels in all
hirsute women.
Non classical Adrenal Hypeplasia
CAH occurs secondary to an enzyme defect leading to
raised androgen production. It is a condition having prenatal onset, is
very severe and gets inherited as an autosomal recessive disease. When
it occurs later in life, the disease has a milder form, when it is known
as late onset, partial or NCAH [78-80]. The symptoform cryptic adrenal
hyperplasia gets discovered only by biochemical screening.
Although all the enzymes recruited for conversion of
cholesterol to cortisol can be affected, commonest ones are
21-hydroxylase (p 450c21), 11 β-hydroxylase (p450c 11) and 3-β
hydroxysteroid dehyrogenase.
21-hydroxylase defect
These Patients presenting with late onset adrenal hyperplasia due to a
21-hydroxylase deficiency, respond to ACTH
stimulation in a modest fashion, between the classical adrenal
hyperplasia-homozygotes response and the mild heterozygote response.
A 21-Hydroxylase deficiency is the commonest
autosomal recessive disorder, which surpasses, cystic fibrosis as well
as sickle cell anemia. Variable clinical presentations can be seen and
it may appear and disappear over time. Thereforethe diagnosis needs
laboratory evaluation.
Genetic diagnosis for known mutations like Cyp21 gene
is not discussed here. The 3 reasons that why it should be diagnosed
arei) Therapy which is accurate should be used, as it maybe longterm.
- Pregnant women with these conditions need genetic counseling, along with assessment of asymptomatic offspring. But for that the father’s carrier status is important for estimating the risk to the fetus. Though the risk for having a child with CAH is very low, the couple must get paternal testing for homo/hetrozygosity. If father is positive, prenatal diagnosis and treatment is reasonably required.
- These Patients might be having a cortisol deficiency, theoretically when they experience severe stress, however this has not been a clinical problem.
Other enzymatic defects
3-β hydroxyl steroid dehydrogenase (type1) deficiency
can present in both ovary and adrenal. Thus significant androgen
production is not seen, but enzymatic activity remains intact in
peripheral tissues. Hence hirsutism, present in this deficiency is due
to a target tissue conversion of the increased secretion of precursors
[81]. Unlike 21-hydroxylase deficiency, no genetic markers are currently
available. Thus for diagnosis, an ACTH stimulation test and
demonstration of altered conversion of 17-hyroxy pregnenolone to 17
hydroxy P (17OHP) ratio is required. Though increased 17OHPresponse to
ACTH stimulation is common in women with hyperandrogenism, response is
consistent with adrenal hyperactivity and not an enzymatic deficiency
[82,83]. Molecular studies fail to find mutations in the genes for the
3β-hydroxy steroid deyrogenase in patients appearing to have
mild-moderate deficiency in 3β-hydroxy steroid dehydrogenase [84-86].
The deficiency present is so subtle, that accurate diagnosis is not
essential. Usual therapeutic approach to hirsutism will be effective.
11β-hydroxylase deficiency is very rare and gets
diagnosed at a younger age. It is not worthwhile to measure the 11deoxy
cortisol response to ACTH stimulation in adult hirsute women, which is
just an effort to detect a very rare deficiency [87].
17 hydroxy Progeterone (170HP)
1-5%of women presenting with hirsutism show a
biochemical response which is consistent with the less severe form of
the adrenal hyperplasia namely 21-Hydroxylase variety[64,65,88-90]. Thus
the relative frequency of NCAH requires the routine screening of 17OHP
screening of women who complain of hirsutism. Routine use of ACTH
stimulation test is not warranted [64,91]. CYP I f CYP21 mutations, are
heterozygous it does not increase the risk, of clinically significant
hirsutism[92]. To make 17OHP testing cost effective, a decision of ACTH
stimulation test can be based on clinically significant hirsutism [87].
If there is a strong family history of androgen
excess, it suggests the presence of an inherited disorder. Hirsutism due
to an adrenal enzyme defect is more severe, beginning at a young age,
mainly at puberty. Short stature and very high levels of androgens
signify a more severe problem. Finally it is worth considering that with
normal baseline steroid levels, even if a woman has subtle enzyme
defects, the management of the problem does not require its discovery.
17OHP needs to be measured early in the morning, to
avoid later deviation due to the diurnal pattern of ACTH secretion. The
baseline 17OHP levels should be <200ng/dl [64,93,94].>200ng/ dL
and <800ng/dlneeds ACTH testing.Levels>800ng/dL are virtually
diagnostic of 21hysroxylase deficiency. DHAS levels are usually normal.
Hallmark of NCAH are increased levels of 17OHP, with a dramatic increase
after ACTH stimulation[89]Still an increased baseline levels of 17OHP
are often not impressive(eg overlapping)with those found in women with
PCOS due to anovulation, and a simple ACTH stimulation must be utilized.
ACTH stimulation test
Intravenous synthetic ACTH(Cortrosyn)is given in a
dose of 250µg.170HP is measured at 0 hrs and after 1 hr at 8AM at any
time of the menstrual cycle. The 1 hr value should be plotted to predict
the genotype, whether homozygote or heterozygote forms of the
21hydroxylase deficiency[95]. Dexamethasone preparation at night before
is unnecessary [96]. 21 hydroxylase deficiency in case of heterozygote
carriers is reflected by ACTH stimulated levels of 17OHP upto 1000ng/dl,
patient having late onset deficiency have levels>1200ng/dl.
For diagnosing 3β hydroxy steroid deficiency in the
ACTH stimulation test, one measures 17OHP and 17hydroxy pregnenolone
ratio. An abnormal 17 hydroxy pregnenolone/17OHP ratio is usually >6
[80]. In this deficiency there is markedly raised DHAS, although serum T
is just normalor mildly increased. To diagnose 11β hydroxylase
deficiency deoxy cortisol will be increased, which is normal in
21hydroxylase defects.
Adrenal gland and anovulation
Adrenal suppression has been known to induce both
ovulation as well as regular menses, because of which empiric therapy
had been advocated in the past. Late onset adrenal hyperplasia cannot
explain all patients presenting with raised DHAS. It is important to
question, is adrenal gland the primary culprit or is raised DHAS
secondary to the altered hormonal milieu associated with anovulation.
There is a possibility that increased adrenal gland activity is due to
effect of estrogen on 3β hydroxy steroid dehydrogenase leading to
anovulation. Although a lot of work has been done to prove the role of E
on 3β hydroxy steroidhydrogenase to prove adrenal insufficieny. Despite
these works to d prove the role of E, there are studies both for
[97-101], and against [102-106] this hypothesis.
This has been compared to its similarity of decreased
levels of 3β hydroxy steroid dehydrogenase in fetal gland and raised
DHAS secretion by the fetal adrenal cortex secondary to E [107,108]. But
studies against this prove that ACTH levels are not raised in adult
anovulatory women [109,110], although the period of raised ACTH
responses would exist only till normal cortisol levels are reachieved,
which is the new set point. Studies of anovulatory female, with inceases
in levels of DHAS, indicate that the raised adrenal activity is because
of a mechanism, within the adrenal gland. It is not secondary to raised
pituitary response to raised CRH and are not because of increased
adrenal response toACTH stimulation [111].
Both androgenand estrogens inhibit 3β hydroxy steroid
dehydrogenase in concentration expected to be in adrenal gland although
it is difficult to achieve with exogenous administration. Stimulation
[112]. Therefore adrenal secretion changes may show the varying actions
of steroids especially E, in different layers of the adrenal cortex
[113]. Steroidogenesis not getting affected by giving exogenous
androgens supports this hypothesis [114].
Therefore this hypothesis that raised adrenal
activity in anovulatory women is induced and maintained by a steady
state of E state, which is seen in anovulation. In patients of PCOS
associated with increased adrenal androgen activity, there exists a
correlation between adrenal sensitivity to ACTH levels and E levels
[115]. But this may be secondary to another mechanism rather than
affecting the 3β hydroxy steroid dehydrogenase. Ovarian suppression with
GnRH agonists has been used with the hope to clarify this puzzle by
assessing function of adrenal after suppression of ovarian steroid
production. Short term suppression for 3-6mths does not have any impact
on the adrenal androgen production [116,117]. But these studies did not
include women with raised DHAS levels. Once women who had raised DHAS
level received 3mths of GnRH agonists, in some but not allwomen, DHAS
levels were suppressed [83,116]. Their has been a suggestion that raised
adrenal androgen production has been due to p450c11,17,20lyase
hyperactivity and in others it is a response which is acquired secondary
to a steady state of E in anovulatory women [83,118]. 92 consecutive
women were studied with hirsutism who on ACTH stimulation showed that
the steroidogenic response which is acquired secondary to anovulatory
hormonal steady state was inconsistent with that of an inherent disorder
of p450c17 [119]. In these women with p450c 17 increased activity,
underlying the disorder maybe secondary to insulin resistance which
leads to hyperinsulinemia [120]. Both insulin and IGF1 receptors are
present on adrenal cells. On infusion of insulin in women it =>a
decrease in adrenal 17, 20 lyase (p450c17) activity which suggests that
insulin reduces the production of adrenal androgen [121,122].
Simple inverse relationahip between insulin and
adrenal androgen levels in anovulatory women does not exist [123]. In a
study by Landay et al. [l24] data was collected regarding androgen
excess between 1987-2002, where 749 patients were diagnosed to have PCOS
by NICHD criteria, and it was found that insulin had a direct effect on
the severity of hirsutism in PCOS and its effects appeared to be
synergistic with TT. Over 90%of the variations in mFGscore was not
related to the factors studied and reflect probably the intrinsic
factors related to pilosebaceous unit function or sensitivity to other
factors which have not been assessed till now [l24] Studying the effect
of bilateral oophorectomy on adrenocortical function in women with PCOS
Azziz et al. [125] 2013 found that total T, free T, and estrone levels
decreased, while their was a significant raise in FSH levels following
oophorectomy. There were no significant differences found in E2, DHEAS,
or SHBG. Basal as well as stimulated androstenedione (
4An) was raised to a significant extent. No significant changes were found in DHA, DHEAS 60 or cortisol (F0); F60 and
F
levels showed a tendency to increase following oophorectomy. Although
levels were not significant. Thus they concluded that ovarian factors do
not seem to contribute significantly to the adrenocortical dysfunction
of PCOS [125]. Age related decrease in DHAS may be related to insulin
resistance [126].


In Anovulatory women ovulation induction can be
explained in part by an ovarian androgen production by circulating DHAS.
A considerable portion of circulating T p roduction by the ovarian
follicles can be attributed to circulating DHAS which serves as a
substrate of prehormone [127] Hence dexamethasoe suppression cannot
separate adrenal and ovarian T secretion, in that both the glands are
involved in a com-plex interacton, with DHAS providing atleast one
mechanism for this interaction.
Because of inconclusive studies once a 17OHP of
200ng/dLis attained, there is no point of considering possibility of
primary adrenal enzyme problems below that and there is little use of
measuring DHAS. One can treat mild adrenal enzyme defects by usual
methods and do not require glucocorticoid administration.
Bidiopathic Hirsutism(IH)
The deinition of IH has varied in the past three
decade. Diagnosis of IH T be used only in hirsute patients with normal
ovulatory function and circulating androgen levels. Just having a
history of regular cycle is not enough to exclude ovulatory dysfunction.
Upto 40%of such hirsute women are anovulatory. Strictly if criteria
areused the diagnosis of IH will be left to <20% of hirsute women.
Studies of Asch et al of the 132 (100%), hirsute women 64 (48%) had
regular cycles, while rest 68 (52%) did not have regular cycles.39 (61%)
had normal ovulation as seen by BBT or luteal phase P, while 25(39%)
did not have normal ovulation. Of the patients having normal ovulation
22 (56%) had normal total and free T and DHAS, while 17 (44%) did not
have normal levels. These 22(56%) patients were the ones having IH,
while the other 44%having normal levels and 39% not having normal BBT,
were considered as functional androgen excess[128].
The pathophysiology of IH Is thought to be due to an
increase in skin 5-α RA activity, probably in both enzymes type I and
type II and possibly a defect in androgen receptor function. These
patients respond to antiandrogens which inhibit 5-α RA activity. New
therapies like new biological modifiers may play an important role in
giving more effec tive therapy for unwanted hair. More investigations
are needed into genetic, molecular and metabolic aspects of the disorder
reviewed by Azziz et al [129].
Treatment of hirsutism
Treatment is addressed in interrupting the steady
state of excess production in view of practically all patients
presenting with a steady state of anovulation and thus
hyperandrogenemia. The production of androgens in hirsute women usually
is a LH-dependent process. Ovarian steroidogenesis suppression depends
on an adequate suppression of LH. Besides the inhibitory actions of the
progesterone component (P), a combination estrogen-progestin
contraceptive gives a further benefit by causing an increase in SHBG,
due to the estrogen component. Araised SHBG causes increased binding
capacity of androgens, which is associated with decrease in circulating
free T levels. P in estrogen-progestin OC’s also inhibits 5-α RA, in the
skin, which further contributes to the clinical impact of OC’s in
hirsutism[130]. Even Estrogen-progestin Contraception can be applied
transvaginally or transdermally and be effective.
Use of low dose OC’s are effective in treating both
acne and hirsutism [131,132]. Even the same beneficial effects with
preparations having low dose levonorgestrel, which was previously
recognized to cause acne at high doses can be used [132,133].
Preparations having desogestrel, gestodene, norgestimate, are associated
with a >SHBG, which further causes marked fall in circulating T
levels, but studies comparing these preparations find no difference in
various androgens measured amongst these [131,134]. Although in theory
one presumes that these preparations should be more effective clinically
in treating acneor hirsutism, in clinical studies no difference in
response was found [135]. Thus all low dose preparations, with the
combined effect of an increase in SHBG and a decrease in free T
production are practically similar in response once used for a year or
more. Using a combination of ethinyl E2in combination with drosperinone
may have greater antiandrogenic effects and lesser metabolic side
effects as compared to other OC’s having other P combinations. This is
in view of structural similarily of drosdperinone with spironolactone.
However one has to use them judiciously where hyperkalaemia is
susapected or drugs which interact, and side effects like hepatic
dysfunction like other OC’s should make a judicious use 136reviewed by
Mathur et al. [136].
Even in women who are placed on antiandrogens, OC’s
give a control of cycle along with contraception. If OC’are
contraindicated or patient is reluctant to use them medroxy progesterone
acetate (MPA), gives good results in a dose of either 150mg/month and
respond poorly to or daily oral MPA in dose of 10-20mg /day. Mechanism
of action of MPA is that it suppresses gonadotrophins, less intensely
and thus the ovarian follicular activity continues. LH suppression is
significant, however T production gets decreased. Although to a leser
degree than OC’s. Besides the T clearance from circulation gets
increased [137]. This is secondary to an induction of liver enzymes
activity although MPA suppresses SHBG, so that less T is bound, but
because total T production is decreased to such great extent that actual
amount of free T is decreased [138]. Hence comparable overall results
is achieved with OC and MPA.
Since hair follicle cycle change takes time, response
to treatment is slow. One must warn the patient that hormonal
suppression of at atleast 6mths is essential before a noticeable
decrease in hair growth occurs. Hence combined treatment with
electrolysis or laser hair removal is not recommended, till hormonal
suppression has been used atleast for 6months. Although new hair
follicles will no longer be stimulated to grow, hair growth which has
been established does not disappear, with hormone treatment alone.
Temporarily one can achieve by shaving, tweezing,
waxing or depilatories [139]. These methods do not stimulate or increase
rate of hair growth as has been the usual belief in the past. But they
need to be used repeatedly as they do not effect inherent hair growth.
For permanent hair removal electrocoagulation of the dermal papilla is
required. One needs to emphasize that electrologists use disposable
needles. One can also use laser for hair removal [140]. Women with dark
hair and light skin, get the best results, because absorption of light
by dark pigments produce local thermal damage to the hair follicle.
Effects of treatment may not be apparent till
previously established hairs are removed. Hence combining ovarian
suppression, preventing new hair growth and electrolysis/laser hair
removal yields most complete treatment. Only in resistant patients other
methods need to be employed, despite 1 year of treatment. Mostly DHAS
levels get suppressed by progestational treatment [132,133]. Although
the exact mechanism of action is not clear. If original cause for
increased DH AS secretion is a steady state of oestrogen (E) causing
anovulation, then change in endocrine, milieu of adrenal gland brought
about with ovarian steroidogenesis restores normal adrenal secretory
pattern. E-P OC may also produce subtle but significant alterations in
ACTH secretion or response of the adrenal gland.
Suppressing adrenal gland to produce ovulation in
some cases having anovulatory cycles is attributable to lowered
circulating androgen levels due to a decrease in contribution of adrenal
glands along with a decrease in amount of DHAS available for conversion
to T within the ovarian follicle. Thus within the follicle androgen
levels are decreased and hence prevents inhibitory actions of androgens
on follicular growth and development. But this is not the replacement
for the first line of drug for inducing ovulation, namely clomiphene. As
far as hirsutism treatment is concerned P suppression of ovarian
steroidogenesis remains the first treatment of choice. Suppression of
adrenal needs to be reserved only for patients having an established
diagnosis of adrenal enzyme deficiency.
In older women where OC’s are contraindicated for
some reason only then a surgical option is considered. Persistent
hirsutism growing in severity is an indication for TAH with BSO.
Similarly patients with hyperthecosis are usually older and respond
poorly to ovarian suppression.
Association of hyperinsulinism with hyperandrogenemia
needs correction of hyperinsulinemia and obesity leading to insulin
resistance besides metformin to control the same. In a multi centre
study Roth et al studied the effects of ovulation induction with
clomiphene, metformin or both in 626 women with PCOS and infertility and
did not find any change in hirsutism with these ovulation induction
techniques as monitored by the mFG criteria [141Roth].
Other methods of treatment
Spironolactone: This is a diuretic
which inhibits aldosterone. Regarding its actions in hirsutism i)it can
directly inhibit 5-αRAii) Inhibition of steroidogenesis can be obtained
by an effect on cytochrome p-450 system, but the suppressive effec ts on
steroids are so variable that the receptor blocking effect is one of
the most important actions [142]. Because of this reason, cortisol, DHA
and DHAS are not changed although androstendione levels are decreased
[143]. Effect on hirsutism is dose related, with a better effect with
200mg/day [144-146]. After some time it can be gradually reduced to a
maintainance dose of 25-50mg / day. Its effects are also slow, just like
progestational agents, and only one can see their effect after 6 months
of treatment. Side effects are minimal, which are diuresis in the
initial few days, with occasional fatigue, and dysfunctional uterine
bleeding. Because of this a progestational agent needs to be added for
anovulatory state to avoid abnormal uterine bleeding, as well as prevent
excessive endometrial hyperplasia because of possibility of
hyperkalaemia, one should not use it in a diabetic patienr, obese or in
patients on drugs which increase potassium levels. It is usually used if
patients find OC’s unacceptable/ disappointing response. One can
combine the peripheral action of spironolactone with OC’s to get a
result, more dramatic, but clinically combined treatment has not shown
more efficacy than single agent therapy [147,148]. Acne can be treated
by a cream having 2-5% spironolactone [149]. No systemic side effects
are seen with this.
Since once androgens are suppressed with
spironolactone there are chances that anovulation gets corrected and
patient may get pregnant due to the ovulation spontaneously and fear of
feminization of a male fetus, but clinically such effects have not been
seen [150]. Still better to keep patient on contraception once on
spironolactone therapy.
Flutamide: Flutamide (Eulexin) acts
at the receptor level, being a nonsteroidal antiandrogen [151]. It
inhibits hair growth directly without many sideeffets, commonest being
dry skin. Still hepatotoxicity is a possibility [152]. Because of this a
low dose approach is recommended as although rare it is a severe side
effect. Daily dose of 250mg can have remarkable effects on hirsutism
within 6months [153]. LFT should be monitored despite low c hance of
liver sideeffects. Comparing 250mg bd of flutamide and spironolactone
100mg OD did not show much difference [154]. One needs to combine OC’s
which is due to antiandrogen effect having the probability of effecting
male fetus development. Although due to hepatotoxicity it is not the
drug of choice but for alopecia, in a study of finasteride, cyproterone,
only 250mg fluta mide was found to be effec tive [155].
Finasteride: This inhibits 5α
RA-thus blocking T to DHT conversion. This enzyme exists in two forms,
type1 and type 2, each getting encoded by different genes. Type I is
found in skin and typeII reductase is predominantly present in
reproductive tissues [156]. Proscar the pharmaceutical preparation used
for prostate cancer inhibits both enzymes, although its potency for
hirsutism treatment as well as alopecia is limited as it is less
effective for type I enzyme. Dose of 5mg inhibits 4hirsutism [157],
without side effects although a smaller dose available as Propecia (1mg)
has been available for men with alopecia. In a RCT all three
finasteride, flutamide and spironolactone 100mg were equally ef fective
[158,159]. But in another RCT spironolactone 100mg/day had greater
efficacy as compared to finasteride [160]. Though effective finasteride
was <effective than flutamide 250mg and spironolactone [161]. Both
forms of finasteride have not been found to be of use in post menopausal
women with alopecia [152,162]. Biggest advantage of finasteride is lack
of side effects butsince DHT inhibition can effect development of
urogenital si nus and urogenital tubercle into male external genitalia,
urethra and prostate, it is essential to use contraception while using
it for hirsutism. Tehvilian found that finasteride gel 0.25%had good
absorption as well as solubilityand hence can be used efficiently
without side effects encountered with the oral drug. Thus it can be used
in patients with IH [163].
Cyproterone Acetate (CA): CA is a
potent progestational agent as its use inhibits both gonadotropin
secretion as well as block androgen binding to its receptor. It has been
used in an E-P contraceptive, known as Diane (2mg CA and 50µg ethinyl
estradiol (E2))or Dianette35 containing 2mg CA and 35µg E2. In reversed
sequential regimen CA is given as 50-100ng/dL from d5-14 with E2 from d
5-25[164]. A comparison of Diane with higher doses of CA although their
effect was greater but was not of clinical significance. Side effects
were similar [165]. Effect of 2mg dose of CA in Dianette was equal to
that of high dose [166]. Side effects are fatigue, oedema, loss of
libido, weight gain and mastalgia. Facial hirsutism
improvessignificantly in 3d month of treatment. Amonophasic low dose OC
combined with100mg apironolactonewas as effective as the reverse
sequential regimen of 50-100µg of CA and E2 [167-170].
Conclusion
Hirsutism, defined as terminal hair on the body of a
female, aff ects 5-10%of women. Of these the commonest cause is
anovulation secondary to PCOS, which is a fairly common disorder
affecting 6-10% of women of reproductive age group. Although ovary is
the main source of androgen excess, evidenc e with synthesis of
androgens from adrenals is exaggerated with 25-50% of PCOS patients
showing an adrenal androgen exces. Androgens can stimulate hair
follicles, producing conversion of vellus type of hairs to terminal
hairs. The degree of production of of dihydro progesterone (DHT) is
determined by the degree of 5-α reductaseM (5-α-RA) and consequently the
effect.
The degree of production of of DHT is determined by
the activity of 5-αRA. Their are two kinds of 5α-RA isozymes. The exact
degree of activity on facial hair and abdominal skin in hirsutism is
unclear. Besides PCOS other hormonal causes like thyroid hormone
deficiency, growth hormone deficiency, or hyperprolactinemiar,
hyperinsulinemia which may act on their own or synergistic increase with
adrenal androgens. Aserum T over 2 ng/ml, warrants exploring for an
androgen secreting tumor. Although in some cases oft resort PCOS massive
virization deepening of voice, receding hairline with a normal
karyotype has been reported in the absence of a tumor, which just needs
simple treatment efforts of controlling hyperandrogenemia. Idiopathic
hirsutism is diagnosed as a last resort even in women having normal
cyclesand is not defined as familial hirsutism. Treatment recommended
initially is an oral contraceptive with low dose ethinyl estradiol
(30µg), preferably with drosperinone or other progestogens. Treatment is
slow and minimum 6mths of treatment is needed to observe any
demonstrable change. Any treatment like laser or electrolysis should be
postponed till this period. Preferrably one uses upto one year of this
treatment. If no response with OC’s add antiandrogens like
spironolactone or finasteride, although spironolactone is preferred. One
can choose drug which has minimum side effects and is cost effective.
GnRH agonists remain the drugs as a last resort. Similarly cyproterone
regimens may be used, Topical applications of spironolactone, fiasteride
may be of help if systemic side effects troublesome. Eflornithine cream
for 8 weeks has been advocated but the authors have not found them to
be very effective alone. Drugs like cimetidine or ketoconazole have an
effect but are not drugs of choice.
For more open
access journals in JuniperPublishers please click on: https://juniperpublishers.com/
For more articles on Gynecology and Women’s
Health please click on: https://juniperpublishers.com/jgwh/
Comments
Post a Comment